Geekflex

Adventures in post-college life

Identity and the Inevitable Cocktail-Party Question

There’s a problem in our culture and in our language that causes us to infer identify based on our occupation. We say “I am a software developer”, “I am an engineer”, “I am a marketing rep” and “I am a student”. We use these statements to build up our identities. When meeting someone for the first time, they almost inevitably asked what’s called The Inevitable Cocktail-Party Question: “What do you do?” They almost never ask “Who are you?”. And what happens when someone actually does ask “Who are you?” … Well, you’ll most likely start with your name immediately followed by your occupation.

This is so freaking wrong. But we can’t help it. It’s imbued in our culture. It’s as if you really are only a reflection of your job. And what if your job doesn’t make you happy? What if it’s something you do to pay the bills and to fund the rest of your life? Well then you might not very much like The Inevitable Cocktail-Party Question.

“If you don’t like The Inevitable Cocktail-Party Question, maybe it’s partly because you don’t like your answer.”1

Throughout my university years I identified with being an engineering student. I embodied that identity in every way I could. I attended every conference and competition available to me. I became involved in my university’s undergraduate Engineering student association. I’ve even won awards for “outstanding contribution to student life”. If you asked me who I was, I would proudly answer “I am a student in software engineering at Concordia University.”

Then, I graduated. Suddenly I was no longer a student. The conferences and competitions were no longer open to me. CUSEC 2009 was my last, big student event that I could participate in. It’s as if the persona and identify that I had embodied with all my spirit was all at once out of context. I suddenly didn’t know who I was anymore. I wasn’t the long-haired, lovably drunk software engineering student anymore, though I was still a long-haired lovable drunk. But that answer didn’t satisfy me at all.

I found myself questioning my identity. How much of who I am was really me, and how much of it was a subconscious attempt to embody the identity and image of a “software engineering student”? Naturally part of the problem is that I had trouble identifying with my new role as a “professional” software developer at a big company. Answering The Inevitable Cocktail-Party Question with “I am a software developer” just doesn’t jive with me. I don’t feel that it accurately portrays who I am the way saying I’m a student did. In other words, I work as a software developer, but there is much more to me than that.

I don’t like my answer to The Inevitable Cocktail-Party Question. As I mentioned, I feel that there is much more to me than my job, but extending this interpretation reveals that my job doesn’t give me enough room to express my own identity. This is why I’m not satisfied simply saying “I am a software developer”, because that is but one small facet of who I am. There are many more aspects to my personality that are hidden, looking for a venue or an outlet with which to be expressed.

I was incredibly lucky to have found outlets for all aspects of myself in my identity as a student, and now I’m struggling to find new outlets in a different context as a member of the working world. I need to change, and recognizing that was not easy. So as a symbol and a tangible reminder of the fact that I’m no longer a student, I finally got a haircut and shed the curly ponytail that I’d kept since the 8th grade.

Skrud's Ex-Hair

Hello, World.


  1. From Po Bronson’s article, “What should I do with my life?” 

4 Comments

4 Responses to “Identity and the Inevitable Cocktail-Party Question”

  1. Christelle says:

    Frankly…I feel the same way (well, as soon as my graduation is confirmed that is). There’s some soul-searching to be done. Thanks for sharing Skrud!

    One thing: I’m not cutting my hair.

  2. Angelo says:

    Glad I’m not the only one who thinks it’s a bit ridiculous to equate a person’s identity, and in some cases one’s worth in society, with their job. We need jobs to pay the bills and the things that you need to enjoy life. That’s it. If some people end up working in jobs that they really like and find stimulating, then they should consider themselves lucky.

    As for answering the “Who are you?” question, maybe it might be easier to start by answering who you aren’t: “You’re not your job. You’re not how much money you have in the bank. You’re not the car you drive. You’re not the contents of your wallet.”

    Oh, and I’m kinda curious about the hair now…

  3. FiG says:

    That was a pretty meaningful post!

    I long ago decided that who I am woudl not be decided by what I do. I never really approached work as a lifestyle.

    There seems to be 2 kinds of people, those that “Live to work” and those that “Work to live”. I like to think that I’m of the latter category.

    BTW, not everyone needs to be some uber awesome recognizable person who “does cool and awesome stuff”. In my opinion, there’s absolutely no problem in living your life and enjoying the simpler things. If you find a high profile job or hobby that’s cool. But also, just spending time with the peopel you love is commendable too!

    As far as cutting your hair, I think it was a good step. Like it or not, it really defined who you were, it especially defined what people thought of you. Sure, by cutting it you will no longer standout in a crowd (unless you’re shirtless!), but that isn’t necessarily a bad thing!

    Oh yeah, you need to come hang out with me at my place at some point. :)

  4. FiG says:

    PS: I still have my ponytail at my parents house from when I cut my hair in cegep.. haha.

Leave a Reply


Creative Commons License
Geekflex by Eitan "Skrud" Levi is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 2.5 Canada License.
The views and opinions expressed on this site are my own, and in no way represent those of my colleagues, employer, or anyone else.
Hosted by Site5